Read

Watch

How This Atheist Helped the Church Prove a Miracle

Published:
November 30, 2023
June 4, 2018
This atheist helped the Catholic Church gather proof of miracles. Read this inspirational story of faith.|Grotto quote graphic about the proof of miracles: "Miracles don't mean squat if they don't succeed in helping us engage with the source of the miracle." —Fr. John Kartje, PhD.

Yes. You read that title correctly. The Vatican relied on Dr. Jacalyn Duffin, an atheist, to help prove a miracle.

A couple of Grotto team members recently attended the Archdiocese of Chicago’s Theology on Tap featuring Fr. John Kartje, PhD, where we heard this atheist’s story.

Dr. Jacalyn Duffin is a medical historian, hematologist, author, and professor at Queen’s University in Ontario, Canada.

The Vatican hired her, by way of a blind study, to provide expert testimony in the case of a second miracle presented in the cause for the canonization of Marie-Marguerite d’Youville, the founder of the Order of Sisters of Charity of Montreal, who was later declared the first Canadian-born saint.

Watch an interview with Dr. Duffin where she explains the study and the Church’s understanding of miracles and says, “Yes, this is a miracle. It’s a thing of wonder. Something that I can’t explain.”


If you are interested in learning more about what determines a miraculous healing, check out the Facebook Live video from Fr. Kartje’s Theology on Tap talk.

Grotto quote graphic about the proof of miracles: "Miracles don't mean squat if they don't succeed in helping us engage with the source of the miracle." —Fr. John Kartje, PhD.

Creators:
Grotto Shares
Published:
November 30, 2023
June 4, 2018
On a related note...
"Dear Heart, a Letter"

"Dear Heart, a Letter"

Maisy Williams

"Noisy Praise"

"Noisy Praise"

Shemaiah Gonzalez

How an Engineer Finds God in Nature

How an Engineer Finds God in Nature

Grotto

Voices of Synod 2018 | Aly Cox

Voices of Synod 2018 | Aly Cox

Grotto

3 Lessons from Two Saints Being Canonized Today

3 Lessons from Two Saints Being Canonized Today

Mike Jordan Laskey

How and Why We Pray for the Dead

How and Why We Pray for the Dead

Matthew Flynn

A Road Trip with the Heart of St. John Vianney

A Road Trip with the Heart of St. John Vianney

Evan Holguin

St. Edith Stein Spotify Playlist | #GrottoMusic

St. Edith Stein Spotify Playlist | #GrottoMusic

Grotto

Is This What Heaven Is Really Going to Be Like?

Is This What Heaven Is Really Going to Be Like?

Josh Noem

"Prayer at Winter Solstice"

"Prayer at Winter Solstice"

Dana Gioia

Why Mass During Holy Week is Anything but ‘Boring'

Why Mass During Holy Week is Anything but ‘Boring'

Ben Wilson

Merry Christmas from Grotto Network

Merry Christmas from Grotto Network

Grotto

Should We Believe Kanye's Conversion Is Authentic?

Should We Believe Kanye's Conversion Is Authentic?

Emily Mae Mentock

Holy Week Spotify Playlist | #GrottoMusic

Holy Week Spotify Playlist | #GrottoMusic

Grotto

Hope for Uvalde

Hope for Uvalde

Javi Zubizarreta

Meet the Church's First African-American Cardinal

Meet the Church's First African-American Cardinal

Grotto Shares

What the Night Sky Holds

What the Night Sky Holds

Brandon Cook

How Magical Realism Helped Form My Imagination

How Magical Realism Helped Form My Imagination

Molly Cruitt

What Is a Sacristy?

What Is a Sacristy?

Grotto

Opening Mass in St. Peter's Square | Synod 2018

Opening Mass in St. Peter's Square | Synod 2018

Grotto

newsletter

We’d love to be pals.

Sign up for our newsletter, and we’ll meet you in your inbox each week.