Read

Dear Therapist: Am I Not “Man Enough” Because I Cry in Therapy?

Creator:
Published:
May 20, 2024
May 20, 2024
Read how this therapist addresses the male mental health stigma from our "Dear Therapist" series.

Dear therapist,

There is a dire issue surrounding men's mental health. Because we don't talk about what's bothering us. We just bottle it all up and bury it deep until it feels like we can no longer take it.

There seems to be a bad vibe about men going to therapy. At least that is my POV. And my generation is going downhill fast with our world in flames (pandemic, recessions, housing market). So we need to talk things out, no?

But I've heard we don't need therapy because "men don't go to therapy."

Should I feel guilty that I go? That I'm not "man enough" for crying in therapy over trauma that has built up for years? That I can feel peace for the first time in a long time? And as if a 100-pound dumbbell was lifted off my chest?

— A Man Who Wants to Break the Stigma

Dear Man Who Wants to Break the Stigma,

You are so right to point out an urgent need to break stigma around men and therapy. Within and outside of our faith-based settings, there can be narratives that “men don’t cry,” “men are less emotional,” or “don’t go to therapy.” When men do cry and allow themselves to feel their emotions, let alone admit the need for support along the way through therapy, friendship, etc., there is a sense that they are being “feminine” “weak” or “soft.”

This messaging disproportionately robs men of access to therapy and is very problematic. Men are much more likely to die-by-suicide, especially as they enter middle age, and suffer immensely with depression, anxiety, job dissatisfaction, panic attacks, substance use issues and compulsive behaviors. Despite these symptoms being treatable, countless men only step foot in therapy when it’s gotten so bad that functioning is significantly impaired, or a family member or circumstance demands it. This only reinforces the belief that “men who go to therapy are weak, broken, or deficient, because we often feel weak, broken, and deficient when we are suffering.

Guilt is an emotion meant to signal when we have acted against our values or have harmed others in some way. Excessive guilt is what we feel when we do something wise and for our good that we’ve been taught we “shouldn’t” do. Therapy, for you, and countless men I work with, is a way to live in accordance with values of health, purpose, faith, etc. Therapy is a good for society and for the individual communities we live in. You will likely feel guilt for your work in therapy because of the stigma you are actively working to break. That will release as you continue to see the fruit your therapy will bear as your peace, insight, and healing unfolds.

I often remind male clients that the perfect man, Jesus Christ, didn’t just cry – He wept. If you want to grow in virtue and Christlikeness, the path involves being willing to connect to the full range of human emotions safely. This includes connecting to your tears, your powerlessness, your inefficacy, as much as your joy, your peace, and your hope.

To be unimpacted by suffering is to cease to be human. We don’t need more men who are disconnected from their humanity. We need more men like Christ.

The men I admire most go to therapy. I am honored to count you among them.

— Dr. Julia Sadusky

Creators:
Grotto, Julia Sadusky
Published:
May 20, 2024
May 20, 2024
On a related note...
How I Found Value in Suffering

How I Found Value in Suffering

Mary Forr

How (& How Not) to Help a Friend with Depression

How (& How Not) to Help a Friend with Depression

Julia Hogan-Werner

The Healing Power of Laughter

The Healing Power of Laughter

Noah Bongiovanni

Marine Veteran Uses Boxing to Help Overcome Depression

Marine Veteran Uses Boxing to Help Overcome Depression

Grotto

It’s Not Easy Being First — Here’s How to Take the Leap

It’s Not Easy Being First — Here’s How to Take the Leap

Molly Cruitt

4 Reasons I'm Cutting Back on Drinking

4 Reasons I'm Cutting Back on Drinking

Andrew Mentock

Be Gentle, For We Are All Grieving

Be Gentle, For We Are All Grieving

Stephanie DePrez

These Bike Rides Make a Positive Impact

These Bike Rides Make a Positive Impact

Grotto

How To Survive Bringing Home a New Baby

How To Survive Bringing Home a New Baby

Tamara Stacey

5 Things To Do When Your Friend Tells You About Trauma

5 Things To Do When Your Friend Tells You About Trauma

Megan O’Brien Crayne

Saints in Your Corner If You Have Anxiety

Saints in Your Corner If You Have Anxiety

Sarah Coffey

How Prayer Affects Your Mental Health

How Prayer Affects Your Mental Health

Mary Claire Lagroue

What You Need to Know About Addictions

What You Need to Know About Addictions

Julia Hogan-Werner

5 Signs You’re Fighting Chronic Loneliness

5 Signs You’re Fighting Chronic Loneliness

Maria Walley

What Gratitude Journaling Taught Me About Happiness

What Gratitude Journaling Taught Me About Happiness

Lillian Fallon

'I Forgive Because I Can't Forget'

'I Forgive Because I Can't Forget'

Migs Mignanelli

What’s on the Other Side of Our Fear?

What’s on the Other Side of Our Fear?

Meghan Franklin

How to Avoid Burnout as a Young Professional

How to Avoid Burnout as a Young Professional

Grace Poppe

What It's Really Like to Lose Someone Close to You

What It's Really Like to Lose Someone Close to You

Sophie Caldecott

How Do You Care for Your Skin?

How Do You Care for Your Skin?

Grotto

newsletter

We’d love to be pals.

Sign up for our newsletter, and we’ll meet you in your inbox each week.